All Facts Matter

Share this post

China's Zero COVID Mess Is Getting Messier

newsletter.allfactsmatter.us
China Matters

China's Zero COVID Mess Is Getting Messier

When Protesters Start Pushing For Regime Change, That's Not A Good Sign.

Peter Nayland Kust
Nov 28, 2022
7
1
Share
Share this post

China's Zero COVID Mess Is Getting Messier

newsletter.allfactsmatter.us

The Chinese Communist Party is getting drawn into a very thorny dilemma.

For most of the decades since Tienanmen Square, Chinese protests have evaded significant sanction by Beijing by focusing their energies on local officials and corrupt local governments (but I repeat myself).

Not any more.

There are reports—and social media posts—showing protesters calling for the unseating of the CCP and the unseating of Xi Jinping.

Protests erupted in Shanghai and on university campuses across the country over the weekend, with crowds calling for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its top leader to step down, in a display of public dissent that the country hasn’t seen in decades.

Put simply, this does not happen in China.

Rather, it did not used to happen—it is happening now.

All Facts Matter
China's Zero COVID Is Becoming A Political Crisis
That China’s Zero COVID has been an abysmal failure at containing even modest outbreaks of SARS-CoV-2 infections has been proven time and again. Beijing Is Having Zero Success With Zero COVID, People Are Having Zero Patience The Price Of Zero COVID: China's Future…
Read more
6 months ago · 13 likes · 12 comments · Peter Nayland Kust

Even more worrisome for Beijing is that not only are protests spreading within Beijing, especially among university students, but the protests have apparently spread to Shanghai.

Twitter avatar for @eefjerammeloo
Eva Rammeloo @eefjerammeloo
This is now on Wulumuqi (=Urumqi) lu in #Shanghai. People holding up white sheets of paper. ‘We don’t need to write anything on it. It is a symbol of the revolution of the people’, someone says. (Don’t manage to send videos.)
Image
5:49 PM ∙ Nov 26, 2022
14,903Likes4,503Retweets

People who presumably are seasoned China watchers are saying this has not happened in recent memory.

Twitter avatar for @david__moser
David Moser @david__moser
I've lived in China for 30 years, and I've never seen such a brazenly open and sustained expression of rage against the PRC govt. WeChat is exploding with protest videos and furious vitriol, and civil disobedience is becoming rampant. This is a serious test of CCP governance.
3:00 PM ∙ Nov 26, 2022
25,891Likes5,627Retweets

Outside of the 2019 protests in Hong Kong, that does appear to have been the case.

While the extent of the anti-regime sloganeering is far from certain at this time (this is very much an unfolding situation and by the time this article is published the facts on the ground almost certainly will have changed), that they are being uttered at all appears to be quite the shock to many Chinese.

Twitter avatar for @WilliamYang120
William Yang @WilliamYang120
From other residents in #Shanghai, who wanted to join the protest but held back in the end due to concerns: "I thought in my life, I would never hear the slogans that were chanted,"
2:30 AM ∙ Nov 27, 2022
521Likes109Retweets

At the same time, there remains a probability that the anti-regime protesters are still a very small minority of the protesters.

Twitter avatar for @WilliamYang120
William Yang @WilliamYang120
"I think there is only one demand from the recent mass protests, which is to end the lockdown and let life go back to normal. The radical slogans shouted in Shanghai today were the result of passion, and I think regime change is the idea from a very small percentage of people."
1:36 AM ∙ Nov 27, 2022
274Likes43Retweets

Obviously, I have absolutely no direct means to confirm any of this, and any assessment of what is currently transpiring must be grounded heavily in the realization that the situation is highly fluid. Any predictions at this point are mere guesses, and not even educated ones.

Still, the fact that the protests are spreading itself creates a problem for Beijing. With protests confirmed in Shanghai, Beijing, and Urumqi, and unconfirmed reports of protests in Nanjing and even Wuhan, this protest is quickly becoming a national movement—something that makes the CCP particularly twitchy (which doesn’t want to lose that very important “Mandate of Heaven” in the eyes of the Chinese people).

Demonstrations occurred throughout the weekend in Beijing, Shanghai and the eastern city of Nanjing, according to witness accounts. Video footage and photos circulating on social media, which The Wall Street Journal wasn’t able to independently verify, suggest protests broke out in several other cities, including Wuhan, the original epicenter of the pandemic. 

Even without the regime change slogans, just the reality of the Chinese people putting nationwide pressure on the CCP to end Zero COVID creates a serious crisis of face for Xi Jinping and the Standing Committee. Their political images—and thus their political fortunes—are at this point almost inextricably tied to the maintenance of the Zero COVID policy. Without getting the protests to die down, there is no way to put a decent interval between the protests and any “discovery” that Zero COVID has been a stellar success and is now no longer necessary.

An announcement like that right now would be a complete humiliation for Xi Jinping.

And to make matters worse, the protesters are not in one location like they were in 1989. As brutal as the Tienanmen Massacre was, it was disturbingly simple: send tanks into Tienanmen Square, shoot or squash anyone who doesn’t turn tail and run.

That strategy today would involve tanks in multiple locations in Beijing and Shanghai, and potentially Nanjing and Wuhan—all under the full gaze of worldwide social media (which as we can see still finds a way to get around the Great Firewall Of China).

Unless Xi Jinping wants to joing Vladimir Putin in genocidal infamy, he’s very much between the Zero COVID rock and the anti-Zero COVID protest hard place.

No, I don’t have any sympathy for him. He authored this monstrosity. It is only fitting he be hoisted by its petard.

All Facts Matter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Alternatively, please consider leaving a tip through Ko-Fi. Thank you always for your support.

Tip Jar On Ko-Fi

7
1
Share
Share this post

China's Zero COVID Mess Is Getting Messier

newsletter.allfactsmatter.us
Previous
Next
1 Comment
David Gallaher
Nov 28, 2022Liked by Peter Nayland Kust

My motto is: People are people's most valuable resource.

The corollary to that is, when dictators kill or jail their own population, they discard the most valuable resource of all, the protestors. So, the worse it gets, the worse it gets.... for ALL of us.

Sad, sad, sad.

Expand full comment
Reply
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Peter Nayland Kust
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing