All Facts Matter

Share this post
China's Zero COVID Is Becoming A Political Crisis
newsletter.allfactsmatter.us
China Matters

China's Zero COVID Is Becoming A Political Crisis

Peter Nayland Kust
Nov 27, 2022
13
14
Share this post
China's Zero COVID Is Becoming A Political Crisis
newsletter.allfactsmatter.us

That China’s Zero COVID has been an abysmal failure at containing even modest outbreaks of SARS-CoV-2 infections has been proven time and again.

  • Beijing Is Having Zero Success With Zero COVID, People Are Having Zero Patience

  • The Price Of Zero COVID: China's Future

  • Zero COVID Means Lockdown Forever

  • "Dynamic" Zero COVID: Zero Logic, Total Chaos

Now, with yet another wave of COVID cases spreading across the country, Zero COVID is encountering an increasing amount of pushback from an increasingly restive population.

Rare protests broke out in China’s far western Xinjiang region, with crowds shouting at hazmat-suited guards after a deadly fire triggered anger over their prolonged COVID-19 lockdown as nationwide infections set another record.

Crowds chanted “End the lockdown!”, pumping their fists in the air as they walked down a street, according to videos circulated on Chinese social media on Friday night. Reuters verified the footage was published from the Xinjiang capital Urumqi.

What is most worrisome for Beijing and the CCP, however, is that the Urumqi protests are hardly an isolated instance of public discontent.

Zhengzhou: Foxconn Factory Workers Reject Zero COVID.

Zero COVID enforcement devolved into a chaotic farce at Foxconn’s iPhone factory in Zhengzhou—the largest fabricator for the Apple devices.

All Facts Matter
China Sees New Surge In Daily COVID Cases
The failure of China’s Zero COVID policy continues to be writ large in the Chinese economy. As cases surge in the Middle Kingdom, so too are lockdowns. The resurgence of COVID cases in China, with 32,695 new local infections recorded for Thursday as numerous cities report outbreaks, has prompted widespread lockdowns and other curbs on movement and busine…
Read more
2 months ago · 6 likes · 2 comments · Peter Nayland Kust

Not only did Foxconn end up essentially paying some workers to leave the facility, workers engaged in open rebellion against Zero COVID, with social media carrying footage of workers tearing down COVID test stations in and around the plant.

Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
JUST IN - Chinese iPhone factory workers in Zhengzhou city are tearing down the COVID test sites now!
Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
BREAKING: Chinese iPhone factory workers walking out of their factory in Zhengzhou City in the protest. They are demanding ''We want to go home, now!'' https://t.co/WIFreCHMCR https://t.co/EGlmMXfJ8A
12:09 PM ∙ Nov 23, 2022
162Likes72Retweets

Ultimately, thousands of workers simply walked off the site, many of them chanting “We want to go home, now!”.

Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
BREAKING: Chinese iPhone factory workers walking out of their factory in Zhengzhou City in the protest. They are demanding ''We want to go home, now!''
Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
BREAKING: Hungry Chinese iPhone factory workers fighting for food now. Some of them haven't eaten for days and rumours said ''some starved to death'' in lockdown. Zhengzhou City October 25th, 2022 https://t.co/8nTgqPpRku https://t.co/D78OGvhiRI
7:39 AM ∙ Nov 23, 2022
366Likes172Retweets

It is worth remembering that Zhengzhou was also were a minor protest erupted just a few weeks ago, after a lockdown at the Foxconn factory triggered food riots.

Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
BREAKING: Hungry Chinese iPhone factory workers fighting for food now. Some of them haven't eaten for days and rumours said ''some starved to death'' in lockdown. Zhengzhou City October 25th, 2022
Twitter avatar for @songpinganq
Songpinganq @songpinganq
Have you heard that more than 200 Chinese cities are in full or partial lockdown now? This was in Zhengzhou -- A city of 14 millions inhabitants yesterday https://t.co/cPSNFma7kV
12:17 PM ∙ Oct 25, 2022
749Likes485Retweets

In Zhengzhou, Zero COVID is being received with something approaching zero compliance.

Urumqi Is Joined By Beijing

In the far west province of Xinjiang, draconian lockdowns have been far more the norm than in China’s central and coastal provinces. Urumqi residents have been confined to their homes for upwards of 100 days at a time, even with new daily cases only numbering around 100.

What has turned the tide of public opinion against Zero COVID, however, has been a fire in an Urumqi high rise apartment complex, in which some 10 people died—with many alleging that the fire’s victims could have survived had the apartment complex not been under lockdown.

Certainly, in Urumqi there is a rising backlash against the government over Zero COVID and its draconian lockdowns.

Twitter avatar for @badiucao
巴丢草 Bad ї ucao @badiucao
Thread/1 Massive protest happened in Ulumuqi,Xinjiang,China after more than 100 days zero-covid city lockdown. People are chanting ‘stop lockdown’ ‘we are human being’
8:59 PM ∙ Nov 25, 2022
2,317Likes970Retweets

There have been unconfirmed social media posts as well which purport to show doors within the apartment complex barricaded and sealed to prevent entry or exit.

Twitter avatar for @fangshimin
方舟子 @fangshimin
【新疆的朋友私信发我的,不敢在朋友圈里发,会被派出所抓,求您推广,让大家知道,他们根本没办法逃生】
Image
Image
7:32 AM ∙ Nov 26, 2022
7,997Likes1,982Retweets

This would flatly contradict the official stance that the people who perished were simply unfamiliar with the complex’ fire saftey measures.

What is surprising about the Urumqi protests, however is that they are being joined by protest demonstrations in Beijing itself.

Twitter avatar for @Nrg8000
Nathan Ruser @Nrg8000
This anti-lockdown protest in the suburbs of Beijing can be geolocated to the South Gate of the Tiantongyuan North #1 Community. From the inside looking out. At 40.0731, 116.4109 google.com/maps/place/40%…
Image
Image
Image
Twitter avatar for @whyyoutouzhele
李老师不是你老师 @whyyoutouzhele
北京天通苑北一区 居民撕破隔离铁皮,走上街头 https://t.co/McL6DCMMVq
10:13 AM ∙ Nov 26, 2022
48Likes9Retweets

There is also a social media dispute over the actual death toll from the fire. While the official count of lives lost, as reported in the New York Post, stands at 10, independent journalist Jennifer Zeng asserted on Twitter that some 44 people burned to death in the building.

Twitter avatar for @jenniferzeng97
Jennifer Zeng 曾錚 @jenniferzeng97
On Nov 23, when a fire broke out in #Urumqi , people’s doors were locked from outside. Fire truck couldn’t get closer either( see my previous tweet). The latest figure says 44 were burnt to death, including a 3 y/o kid. That’s one of the reasons for today’s protests.
10:17 PM ∙ Nov 25, 2022
1,634Likes1,129Retweets

Zero COVID protocols are also being blamed for a shoddy response by city firefighters, which contributed to the death toll.

Local Officials Have Learned Nothing From Shanghai

During the Shanghai lockdown this past spring, city officials came under a fair amount of heat for their seeming inability to manage the logistics of food distribution during a total citywide lockdown. However, while Shanghai under lockdown acquired a Dante-esque image, the basics of public safety—police and fire brigades—by and large managed to function. Not so in Urumqi; if Jennifer Zeng’s recitation of events is correct, the fire brigade in Urumqi simply failed to respond appropriately.

In both Urumqi and Zhengzhou, local officials have simply failed to manage the most basic of city services with any degree of competency. Public health and public safety are simply falling apart when a city goes into lockdown under Zero COVID protocols.

Whatever lessons there were to be learned from Shanghai, apparently they were not learned in Urumqi or Zhengzhou.

What is being learned from Urumqi and Zhengzhou is that Shanghai was not an isolated, exceptional situation, but was rather what the Chinese people can expect in a city locked down under Zero COVID. The people learning that lesson are the ordinary Chinese citizens in other cities—particularly Beijing.

The message that is spreading alongside the SARS-CoV-2 virus appears to be that Zero COVID is an abysmal failure, that it does not stop the virus but simply makes life literally unlivable. That message is a direct refutation of the rationale proffered by the CCP for perpetuating Zero COVID.

The Chinese people are telling Xi Jinping that Zero COVID is a wrong policy and the government is wrong for persisting in it. Whether Xi Jinping has the political acumen both to hear that message and to find a face-saving way to accomodate that message is as yet an open question.

All Facts Matter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Alternatively, please consider leaving a tip through Ko-Fi. Thank you always for your support!

Tip Jar On Ko-Fi

14
Share this post
China's Zero COVID Is Becoming A Political Crisis
newsletter.allfactsmatter.us
Previous
Next
14 Comments
Kay Allen
Writes Kay’s Newsletter
Nov 27, 2022Liked by Peter Nayland Kust

If this is what it takes to make the slave population there finally rise under en masse and take down the tyrannical overlords, then good. Their obedience has been their undoing thus far.

Expand full comment
ReplyGift a subscriptionCollapse
3 replies by Peter Nayland Kust and others
The BarefootHealer
Writes Barefoot Musings
Nov 27, 2022Liked by Peter Nayland Kust

I love your work Peter and much thanks from me to you,for all thatyou have been doing to draw attention and connect the threads around the world. Im old enough to remember Tiananmen square. These "uprisings" look different. Yes different time, different place, different tech. There's not the sense of urgency that is common to rebellious uprisings gaining traction.

Expand full comment
ReplyGift a subscriptionCollapse
1 reply by Peter Nayland Kust
12 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Peter Nayland Kust
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing